Real-world history
What Bungie's sandbox developers said (2022–2024)
Last researched November 1, 20269 min read
Sources and builds for this page
Applies to: d2_wq (Season of Plunder, 2022) → d2_tfs (previews, 2024); later changes noted per item
five Bungie developer interviews listed on destiny2.science, checked against each video's YouTube transcript (auto-generated captions, read 2026-11-01); community summaries on r/DestinyTheGame (Wayback Machine copies) as the finding aid; patch notes cited per item via the destiny.bungie.org archive
Confidence:AOfficial: Bungie or the ManifestBRead from the game filesCMy inference from dataDCommunity sourceEHypothesis
Between 2022 and 2024 Bungie's weapons and armor designers went on community podcasts and answered sandbox questions in detail. These are the closest thing to a primary source for why the sandbox works the way it does. I first read them through the summaries Court and legoleflash posted, then checked every claim against the videos' transcripts. Each claim below links to the moment in the video where it's said.
How much to trust this
It's a developer speaking, not Bungie documentation, so nothing here is conf. A on its own. A claim reaches A only when a patch note shows it shipped. The transcripts are YouTube's automatic captions: they don't name speakers and they mishear game terms. Where two developers were on the show, I name the speaker only when the topic makes it clear (Thompson leads armor; Proctor and Mercules work on weapons).
The interviews
| Date | Show | Bungie guests | Summary by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022-10-26 | Podcast Versus Enemies, ep. 38 (video, 1 h 35 min) | Chris Proctor (weapon features lead), Vivian Becks (weapons designer) | Court (Wayback) |
| 2023-05-15 | Podcast Versus Enemies, ep. 63 (video, 1 h 37 min) | Chris Proctor, Rodney Thompson | Court (Wayback) |
| 2023-07 | Massive Breakdowns, ep. 302 (video, 2 h 10 min) | Mercules, Kyt Kutcha (QA) | legoleflash (Wayback) |
| 2024-02-28 | Firing Range, ep. 64 (video, 2 h 31 min) | Mercules | Court (Wayback) |
| 2024-03-26 | Podcast Versus Enemies, ep. 99 (video, 1 h 16 min) | Chris Proctor | Court (Wayback) |
Damage stacking
- The core problem: In late 2022 the weapons team called multiplicative buff stacking a major source of trouble. They named three fixes they'd discussed: diminishing returns, a hard cap on damage, or switching to additive stacking. The speaker preferred additive: two +100 % buffs would give 300 % instead of 400 % (ep. 38, 36:42, 37:47).
- Why it didn't happen: By May 2023 both guests still wanted it, but it would need engineering work plus a full rebalance of every damage source, on top of years of content built around the current numbers. The real question was what else to drop to make room (ep. 63, 1:12:37). It never shipped: Court's 2026 model still multiplies across categories (see buff stacking).
- Divinity: Much of the game's content assumes players can easily apply a 30 % weaken. Season 19 cut Divinity's weaken from 30 % to 15 %, and its precision cage still works alongside a stronger weaken from another source, which Bungie's test team checked twice. The team considered cutting its uptime or making it harder to use, but kept its consistent damage as its identity (ep. 38, 30:54, 31:44, 33:38). Divinity's cut and a 25 % Gjallarhorn cut shipped in update 6.3.0 (2022-12-06, A).
- One home per kind of bonus (Thompson, 2023). An armor bonus tied to one element uses the Surge buffs. A bonus for every weapon uses the same empowering buff as Empowering Rift. The goal is more ways to reach the same buffs, not more buffs that stack. Anything that does stack on top should be narrow, like one weapon type, or hard to set up, and the seasonal artifact is another place for extras (ep. 63, 1:07:15). Path of the Burning Steps was moved onto the Surge numbers as part of this. It and Eternal Warrior jump straight to the top tier, higher than leg Surge mods give (40:09, 41:03). Update 7.1.0 (2023-05-23) shipped that change (A).
Weapons
- Balance target (Mercules, 2023). Weapons are tuned for a "base sandbox": Heroic Nightfalls and Legendary campaigns. Anything easier feels overpowered and anything harder feels underpowered. A hand cannon will never one-shot red-bar enemies in a Grandmaster at base. If weapons were balanced for GMs, activity designers would scale the next activity up to match, and the two would chase each other: Bungie calls this the arms race. GMs are still tested, just not balanced for (ep. 302, 24:58, 25:46).
- Primaries hit harder than in Shadowkeep. Many weapons already deal more precision damage than in Shadowkeep and usually double the body-shot damage, so going back to Shadowkeep's model would be a big nerf (ep. 302, 26:22).
- Range costs power. When designers test an encounter, they check whether players can hide far away and pick enemies off safely. If that would trivialize the fight, it gets designed out. Buffing snipers too far would let special weapons outclass heavies (ep. 302, 19:03, 19:33).
- Fire rates rarely change (Mercules, 2023). In his words, "the game is 30 ticks". So a 600 RPM Adaptive and a 450 RPM Precision auto rifle differ by one frame, and 600 against 720 by one frame on every other shot. Small changes feel big, so fire-rate boosts mostly go on short-lived perks (ep. 302, 1:49:28, 1:50:02). Both examples only work at a 30 Hz step: at 60 Hz the first gap would be two frames and 720 RPM would land on exactly 5 frames, with no alternation (C).
- Reserves follow magazine size. With a fixed reserve, a huge magazine could end up with half a magazine in reserve. So the reserve is calculated live from the magazine, which is also why it's hard to show in game; Bungie was looking into it in 2023 (ep. 302, 21:17). Edge of Fate replaced random ammo with the ammo meter (A).
- Season 22 fixes (Mercules, 2023):
- Running two special weapons gave more heavy ammo because of a bug, which was fixed (ep. 302, 14:40).
- Bows had no damage falloff only because of a long-range hit-registration problem, also fixed (23:53).
- Some weapons get only about 60 % of the normal benefit from Zoom, and Zoom no longer pushes out damage falloff (1:55:06).
- Airborne Effectiveness (Mercules, 2024). It always existed internally. Before Forsaken you couldn't change it. Forsaken added Heat Rises and Icarus Grip, and two sources weren't worth a stat. In the old system, jumping widened the accuracy cone about three times and halved aim assist; today aim assist drops by about 75 % in the air. At 0 AE you keep half the old aim assist, and at 100 AE about 110 %. Removing AE would make guns far less accurate in the air than they are now, worst for exotics that never had Icarus Grip, like Ace of Spades. The Final Shape added stacking helmet mods (+15 / +25 / +30 AE) (Firing Range 64, 1:17:40, 1:20:58).
- Origin traits were expected at launch to be about half as strong as a normal trait, though that was never pinned down. They also succeeded at making players care where a weapon came from. Traits that only worked in one activity (the Gambit one in The Witch Queen) were being reworked to work everywhere (ep. 38, 11:19, 12:09).
- Adepts: At first the team thought Adepts would be purely cosmetic, and players cared about them more than expected. By raw power they were about 2–5 % stronger in 2022 (Proctor, ep. 38, 24:48). Mercules gave the target as 5–10 % in 2023, enough that a 4/5 Adept matches a 5/5 normal roll thanks to the Adept mod and masterwork (ep. 302, 1:09:00). Crafted weapons with enhanced traits beating Adepts was "a bad situation", so Lightfall raid Adepts got a path to enhanced traits (ep. 38, 19:21, 19:46). Edge of Fate later replaced Adepts with gear tiers (A).
- Enhancing everything else: In 2023 the long-term plan was to let every weapon that can't be crafted, from world drops to raids and dungeons, be enhanced. Choosing the barrel and magazine stays special to Adepts (ep. 63, 1:33:19). In 2024 Proctor said the Into The Light weapons and others would get enhanced traits in The Final Shape. Only raid Adepts, whose normal versions can be crafted, pick barrel and magazine (ep. 99, 9:27).
- Catalyst records are not catalysts (Mercules, 2024). The behind-the-scenes setup for a catalyst is built when an exotic is made, and sometimes isn't hidden, so the API seems to show a catalyst that doesn't exist. No catalyst has been held back for being too strong. The only finished one that never shipped was an experimental Malfeasance catalyst from around Forsaken, and it probably just didn't work. An early idea for Malfeasance's catalyst, Cascade Point, was uncontrollable. The "High Noon" Last Word catalyst rumor isn't a catalyst (Firing Range 64, 1:06:17, 1:12:06, 1:12:46).
- Recoil: Deterministic recoil patterns stay. The recoil direction stat still works as before, but now nudges a different starting pattern, which is why the number and the feel can disagree (ep. 99, 34:01).
Abilities and armor
- One set of verbs: Weapon perks that use subclass verbs use the very same versions, with a few tuning handles such as duration (ep. 38, 6:40). Burn is an older version of Scorch, and Scorch is much stronger. The two are easy to confuse, and the team wants verbs that stand apart (40:53, 41:11).
- Exotic armor timeline (Thompson, 2023). An exotic takes six to nine months from concept to release. Art starts first because it takes longest. Then come a few months of paper design, the designers building it in the engine themselves, three to four months of playtests and two to three of bug fixing, overlapping (ep. 63, 54:41, 54:58). Balance uses usage and success rates per exotic, down to which exotics are worn when a GM team wipes (46:04).
- Buildcrafting 2.0 started as paper design in summer 2021, for Lightfall (ep. 63, 12:43).
PvP
Time to kill (Mercules, 2023). Kills under half a second are avoided because the victim has no time to react. He thought TTKs were "a little on the fast side" and wasn't against slowing the ones creeping toward 0.6 s, but primaries need to kill fast for three reasons:
- special weapons and other one-hit kills,
- abilities that heal or add health and damage resistance,
- fast movement that lets players run from fights.
Live primaries killed in 0.6–1.0 s, Checkmate's in 0.8–1.2 s, and hand cannons were unchanged. Bungie also treats the 140 RPM hand cannon as its baseline (ep. 302, 1:19:10, 1:19:51, 1:21:27).
Kills over Expected is a balance measure that can be split by skill, playlist and date. Usage drags it down as less skilled players pick up a popular gun (ep. 302, 1:08:20, 1:11:29).
Checkmate wasn't meant to replace normal Crucible. It was a source of data for tuning it. The March 2024 update raised health by 15 % and ability cooldowns by 15 % (Firing Range 64, 5:01, 6:53). Most resilience breakpoints moved from tier 6–7 down to 3, with a few new ones near the top: for 120 RPM hand cannons, 7 resilience turns two crits and a body shot into three crits. 120 RPM scouts keep that combination at every tier (44:55, 46:09, 35:32). Armor 3.0 later removed resilience (see PvP history).
Into The Light (2024)
The studio collected about 40 weapons it wanted to bring back, from its own ideas and years of player requests, and could make 12. Older weapons cost more to bring back, so the 12 mix old and new (ep. 99, 30:02, 32:04). Strong legendaries stay legendary even when players ask for exotic status. They don't meet the exotic bar for visuals, audio and feel, and new legendary subfamilies are more likely (23:38). Only the limited-edition Into The Light drops can roll two traits in columns 3 and 4 (5:49).
What the summaries got wrong
These were on this page when it relied on the community summaries. The transcripts don't support them:
- Origin traits "started as Foundry traits": That was the host listing favorite traits, not Bungie's history (ep. 38, 10:29). "They ended up stronger than intended" isn't said either.
- "Bungie wanted to merge Burn and Scorch." Too strong. The point was to make verbs easier to tell apart.
- "Exotic armor is locked once art starts." Art starts first because it takes longest. "Nerfs try to keep the original playstyle" isn't in the video.
- "Glaives came down because specials must not out-damage heavies." The sniper half is said (19:03). The glaive part isn't.
- A "net fun" balance measure: Not in the video. Kills over Expected and usage are.
Not found in the captions, so treat as unverified:
- Divinity on about 40 % of players in some Grandmasters.
- An Arc-only stacking debuff that was tried and dropped.
- The last per-weapon hidden stat (Ikelos SMG) being removed.
- Recoil set per subfamily and sights drawn by hand.
They may be in a part the auto-captions garbled.
Open questions
- The four unverified claims above: search the captions again with misspellings ("icolos", "divinity's"), or listen to the right section.
- The February 2023 "Enhancing Weapon Crafting" article: did it cover only raid Adepts? (see systems changes).